The Sikkim High Court has approached the Supreme Court over a shortage of judges that has prevented it from hearing certain intra-court appeals. Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque has written to Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant, seeking arrangements to transfer five pending writ appeals to another High Court. The Sikkim High Court currently has a sanctioned strength of three judges but only two serving judges. Consequently, it faces an institutional difficulty in forming benches to hear appeals against decisions delivered by its own single-judge benches.
Gauhati High Court Quashes Pranab Doley’s NSA Detention
Sikkim High Court Faces Judicial Strength Shortage
The High Court of Sikkim currently operates with two judges against its sanctioned strength of three. Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque and Justice Bhaskar Raj Pradhan are the two serving judges.
The shortage has created a specific problem for intra-court appeals. These appeals allow litigants to challenge decisions delivered by a single judge before a larger bench within the same High Court.
However, both serving judges have delivered decisions that are now under challenge in the pending appeals. Therefore, the court cannot form an appropriate division bench from its existing judicial strength to hear those matters.
The situation has left five writ appeals awaiting adjudication. Furthermore, the delay has raised concerns about timely access to justice for the litigants involved.
Chief Justice Writes to CJI Surya Kant
Chief Justice Mustaque wrote to CJI Surya Kant seeking an appropriate arrangement to address the institutional difficulty. His communication requested the transfer of five pending writ appeals to another High Court or another suitable arrangement.
In the letter, Mustaque highlighted the possible consequences of continued delays. He noted that prolonged pendency could affect the timely delivery of justice and the legitimate expectations of litigants.
The Chief Justice also stressed the need for an arrangement that would allow the appeals to proceed without unnecessary delay.
The request reflects an administrative challenge rather than a dispute over the merits of the pending cases. Its immediate purpose is to ensure that litigants retain access to an appropriate appellate forum.
Supreme Court Treats Letter as Suo Motu Petition
The Supreme Court has taken up the matter following the communication from the Sikkim Chief Justice. A bench led by CJI Surya Kant, along with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, treated the administrative letter as a suo motu writ petition.
The bench also sought a response from the Union government. This step brings the issue before the Supreme Court for consideration and allows the Centre to respond to the proposed arrangement.
The proceedings focus on resolving the institutional difficulty affecting the five appeals. However, the conversion of the letter into a petition does not itself mean that the Supreme Court has approved their transfer.
The next steps will depend on the response and any further directions issued by the apex court.
Departure of Justice Meenakshi M Rai Reduced Court Strength
The shortage followed a change in the Sikkim High Court’s judicial composition. Justice Meenakshi M Rai, the first woman judge of the High Court, moved to the Patna High Court after her appointment as its Chief Justice in June 2026.
Her departure reduced the Sikkim High Court’s working strength to two judges. Chief Justice Mustaque had assumed charge on January 4, 2026.
Justice Bhaskar Raj Pradhan remains the other serving judge. As a result, the court has struggled to constitute the required benches for the pending intra-court appeals.
The situation demonstrates how a single judicial vacancy can affect the functioning of a smaller High Court. In particular, limited judicial strength can create difficulties when judges must hear appeals against decisions delivered by their own single-judge benches.
Why Intra-Court Appeals Matter
Intra-court appeals form an important part of the appellate process in High Courts where the applicable rules permit them. They allow a larger bench to review certain decisions delivered by a single judge.
Such appeals provide litigants with another judicial forum within the same High Court. They can address legal questions, procedural concerns and challenges arising from single-judge decisions.
However, these proceedings require an appropriately constituted bench. The judges who hear an appeal must meet the applicable legal and procedural requirements.
In Sikkim, the shortage has made that arrangement difficult for five pending writ appeals. Therefore, transferring the matters to another High Court or creating another suitable arrangement could help resolve the immediate problem.
The Supreme Court’s consideration may also clarify how courts can address similar institutional constraints when their working strength falls below the level needed for particular proceedings.
Conclusion
The Sikkim High Court has sought Supreme Court intervention after its working strength fell to two judges. Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque requested the transfer of five pending writ appeals or another suitable arrangement. The Supreme Court has treated his letter as a suo motu writ petition and sought the Union government’s response. The proceedings now focus on finding a way to ensure that the pending appeals receive timely judicial consideration.
FAQs
1. Why has the Sikkim High Court approached the Supreme Court?
The High Court faces a shortage of judges that prevents it from constituting suitable benches to hear five pending intra-court appeals.
2. Who wrote to Chief Justice of India Surya Kant?
Sikkim High Court Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque sent the communication.
3. How many judges are currently serving in the Sikkim High Court?
The court has a working strength of two judges against its sanctioned strength of three.
4. How many writ appeals are awaiting adjudication?
Five writ appeals are pending because of the institutional constraint.
5. What action has the Supreme Court taken?
A bench led by CJI Surya Kant treated the Chief Justice’s letter as a suo motu writ petition and sought the Centre’s response.
6. Why did the Sikkim High Court’s working strength fall?
Justice Meenakshi M Rai’s appointment as Chief Justice of the Patna High Court in June 2026 reduced the Sikkim High Court’s working strength.
